Showing posts sorted by date for query luck. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query luck. Sort by relevance Show all posts

The Beatitudes and Human Flourishing: Part 2, Makarios and Asre

As introduced in the last post, Jonathan Pennington argues in his book The Sermon on the Mount and Human Flourishing: A Theological Commentary that the best English translation we have for the Greek word makarios in the Beatitudes is "flourishing." This is, obviously, a contrast with the more traditional translation of "blessed." 

So, how does Pennington justify this choice?

A critical piece of Pennington's argument concerns how makarios maps onto the Old Testament.

To appreciate this argument, a quick historical recap is in order. As you know, the Old Testament was written in Hebrew. However, around 250–200 BC, a few centuries before Jesus, Jewish scholars translated the Old Testament into Greek. This translation was called the Septuagint. And the Septuagint was the Bible of the apostles and early Christians. 

As a Greek translation of the Old Testament, the Septuagint allows scholars to correlate Greek words in New Testament with Hebrew words in the Old Testament. The process is simple. For a given Greek word in the New Testament we can observe where that same Greek word shows up in the Septuagint. We then examine the Hebrew words associated with the Septuagint's translation. This method helps correlate Old Testament meanings with New Testament words. 

Okay, so where do we find the Greek word makarios used in the Septuagint? What Hebrew words are associated with it?

To start, Pennington notes that it's rare to find in the Septuagint a strict one to one correspondence between a Greek word and an associated Hebrew word. That is to say, we don't often find Greek/Hebrew synonyms. Mostly what we find in the Septuagint is a variety of Hebrew words associated with a single Greek word. But against that general trend, we do find an exception with the Greek word makarios. As Pennington observes, the Hebrew word asre in the Old Testament is always translated as makarios in the Septuagint. This suggests a tight correspondence between the Hebrew asre and the Greek makarios.

So, what does asre mean in the Old Testament?

To start, while there is some debate here, the word asre come from Semitic and Egyptian roots meaning "prosperity, good luck, and happiness." Crucially, asre is mainly found in the Wisdom tradition of the Old Testament, mostly Psalms and Proverbs. Of the forty-five occurrences of asre in the Old Testament, twenty-six are from the Psalms. 

This connection with the Wisdom tradition is important for Pennington. The Wisdom tradition is less invested in the "if/then" contingencies of the Deuteronomic covenant, especially how those relate to the cultic practices of Israel. The Wisdom texts are more interested in a life well-lived than in adherence to Levitical prohibitions. As Pennington summarizes, "Asre describes the happy state of the one who lives wisely. In this sense it is closely related to salom [shalom]." Pennington continues:

Thus, asre refers to true happiness and flourishing within the gracious covenant God has given. Like the prophetic literature, the Psalms offer the promise of flourishing and happiness (fertility, prosperity, security) through faithfulness to the Lord...There is a struggle in Israel about which way to live, and the Psalms play an important part in creating the vision of the only path to true flourishing...

The other place asre regularly occurs is Proverbs, which also makes an appeal to find full human flourishing through wise living. In Proverbs the asre one is primarily the person who finds wisdom and lives wisely...This person is naturally extolled as "happy" and "flourishing."

We can observe this holistic view of flourishing in how asre regulates the vision of Psalm 1:

Blessed [Hebrew: asre; Septuagint: makarios] is the man
who walks not in the counsel of the wicked,
nor stands in the way of sinners,
nor sits in the seat of scoffers;

but his delight is in the law of the Lord,
and on his law he meditates day and night.

He is like a tree
planted by streams of water
that yields its fruit in its season,
and its leaf does not wither.
In all that he does, he prospers.

Notice what we have here in Psalm 1. A picture of human human flourishing. The one who is makarios is nourished ("like a tree planed by streams of water"), full of vitality ("its leaf does not wither"), and fecundity ("yields its fruit in its season"). Simply put, the one who is makarios "prospers." 

The point for Pennington is that this vision of asre in Psalm 1 isn't a vision of behavior/reward, that if I do X then I will receive Y. That sort of if/then contingency is how we often think of the Beatitudes, that if I am, say, pure in spirit then I will receive a reward/blessing. By contrast, the vision of asre in the Wisdom tradition, argues Pennington, is describing something more organic, integral, and holistic. Not blessing as mere reward, but a vision of human flourishing--an integral way of being in the world characterized by vitality, fecundity, and prosperity.

If this is so, then the Beatitudes aren't setting before us a command/reward framework. "Do X and you will be Blessed." Rather, in the Beatitudes Jesus is describing a, very paradoxical, vision of human flourishing itself. 

RenƩ Girard and Moral Influence: Part 3, Scarcity and Anxiety

Soon after the publication of Unclean I was asked to present a paper, for the very first time, at a theological conference. The conference was devoted to the work of RenĆ© Girard and I was asked to share how I integrated Girard's work into my research with disgust psychology. 

My paper shared the analysis from the last post, how attributions of disgust, marking an individual or group as "unclean," selects the scapegoat and masks the scapegoating mechanism. 

During the Q&A after the presentation I got into my first debate and disagreement with Girardian thinkers. 

The issue went to a footnote in Unclean where I named anxiety as a cause of social scapegoating, an anxiety rooted in scarcity. This goes against Girardian orthodoxy which places mimetic desire at the heart of the scapegoating mechanism. What I discovered in that exchange was how central mimetic desire was to many of Girard's followers. For many Girardians, mimetic desire is the anthropological key that unlocks the treasure trove of sociological and theological insights. My interest in Girard was less anthropological. My feeling is that scapegoating has lots of sources and causes, not just one. In fact, I believe that scapegoating is caused more due to fear than mimetic rivalry. Scarcity, I felt, was the main driver of scapegoating.

For example, as I pointed out at the conference, there is an assumption of scarcity behind Girard's theory of mimetic desire and rivalry. Girard's model is often diagramed as a triangle between a subject, a model, and an object. I observe a model desiring an object. And through mimesis, I imitate that desire. Consequently, my desire brings me into rivalrous competition with the model over the desired object. Two of us are now wanting the same thing.

Notice, I shared at the conference, how there is only one object of desire for two individuals. That's an assumption of scarcity. Two are fighting over an object only one can possess. By contrast, what if there were many objects being desired by the model? What if we assume abundance instead? In that situation, my mimetic desire wouldn't bring me into competition or rivalry as there would be plenty to go around. My point was that desire only brings about competition when the object being desired is scarce, where there will be winners and losers, haves and have nots. 

An assumption of scarcity also sits behind rivalries due to superior status, like we see in racism and nationalism. It's a game of King of the Mountain. Only one party can be "the best," sitting atop the hierarchy of value. Only one nation can be "the greatest nation in the world." Same with rankings of racial superiority and supremacy. If everyone, by contrast, could be the greatest or best we wouldn't be fighting over that top spot. But since only one among the many rivals can be "the best" we fight over that scarce, only-one-can-have-it, designation. By definition, there can only be one GOAT. 

I think these are good arguments, but you can rest assured that the Girardians had their rebuttals at the conference. And they were good ones. Look at children, they said, playing with toys. There can be plenty of toys around, but one child will want the toy another child is playing with just because that child is desiring it, having fun with it, even when there are plenty of identical toys at hand. Plus, what about mirror neurons! And so on, and so forth.

But here's my point. We can both be right! Like I said, I think scapegoating happens for lots of reasons, and not just mimetic desire. And I'm convinced that scarcity is one of the major reasons, or paranoia about a potential future scarcity, real or imagined. Why, for example, did the Nazis scapegoat the Jews? Perhaps it was due to mimetic desire. But I think one of the major reasons was the economic hardships the Germans suffered due to the Treaty of Versailles. That experience of scarcity and loss, economic and in terms of national shame, caused the Germans to look around for someone to blame. Hitler pointed the finger at the Jews. And continued, during his rise to power, to point the finger at the Jews as a persistent and ongoing threat and danger. Fear, again, plain and simple.

Think also about how illegal immigrants get scapegoated. They are taking our jobs and soaking up our benefits! Illegal immigrants are stealing scarce goods. Throw in descriptions of illegal immigrants as rapists, drug traffickers, and criminals, as dangerous threats, and a lot of fear gets stoked, fear that comes out in scapegoating. And listen, I'm not here to adjudicate the shape of a just and humane immigration policy. I'm just asking, as a psychologist, what best explains "Build That Wall!" xenophobia? It could be mimetic desire. But I think the simplest reason is scarcity and fear. Fear, real or delusional, that an illegal immigrant is going to take away a job, receive undeserved social benefits, or hurt someone. 

But again, Girardians have their answers to all this. The theory has to stay pure and uncontaminated. Only one cause for scapegoating is allowed. Everything must get stuffed into the explanatory box of mimetic desire. My view, by contrast, is that people scapegoat for lots of reasons. Mimetic desire is one. Scarcity-based anxiety, legitimate or paranoid, is another. You can think of some more. 

And if this is so, we reach another dim conclusion. Anxiety is endemic to the human condition. As I describe it in The Slavery of Death, as biodegradable creatures in a world of real or perceived scarcity fear will be our constant companion. Given this, more is needed than simply exposing the mimetic roots at the heart of sacred violence. Overcoming our anxiety is necessary. Which means overcoming the biological and material realities of human finitude and limitation. And Girard's theory just doesn't traffic in those sorts of ontological issues. Simply put, Girard's theory of "atonement," how we are saved, does nothing to address the harsh material realities that cause human persons and societies to act self-interestedly and violently. 

If life is like being on the Titanic, my problem isn't that you and I desire the same lifeboat. Our problem isn't mimetic desire. Our problem is scarcity, that there are not enough lifeboats to go around. You and I want the same boat because, tragically, there is only one of them left. And if your "plan of salvation" is to encourage frighted animals to give up their seat on the lifeboat in an act of heroic self-sacrifice, to "stand in solidarity" with the doomed, well, best of luck with that. Most people are going to try to get their loved ones onto that boat, at the expense of you and yours, and be very tempted to jump aboard themselves. This is a natural human response. As I describe in The Slavery of Death, fear tempts us toward self-interest. And there's nothing in Girard's theory, insofar as it eschews ontological issues, that can help us escape the underlying anxiety of the human predicament.  

The Moral, the Existential, and the Ontological: Part 4, Moral Drift

In this post I want to gather up some observations I've made before, but using them to illustrate the moral, existential, and ontological layer framework I've been floating in this series.

The question I want to focus on in this post is this: What are some of the things that happen when the moral layer becomes separated from the layers beneath it? 

There are so many things to say, but let me focus on things I've shared over the years and in some of my books.

Let me start with some things about when the moral layer becomes separated from the existential, narrative, and symbolic layer. The first thing to say, as I have throughout this series, is that man does not live by morals and politics alone. I'll say for the fourth post in a row: Meaning is the bread of life. So, while the Judeo-Christian values of liberal humanism and political progressivism may provide one with a moral compass and political commitments, this is insufficient to fill the existential vacuum of secular modernity. 

Another thing that happens when the moral layer is separated from the narrative and symbolic layer is that the moral vision becomes thin and impoverished. For example, when we disembed social justice from the moral matrix of the Judeo-Christian worldview crucial moral commitments and capacities are left behind. This turns "social justice" into a blunt instrument, and is one of the reasons social justice so often goes awry. Here's how I described this in Hunting Magic Eels:

As the saying goes, when all you have is a hammer, everything starts to look like a nail. Justice is just one tool in our moral toolbox. A critical, essential tool. But one tool can’t do all the moral work life demands of us. Justice is a hammer, and when you’re looking at a nail— say, oppression—the hammer is the tool to pick up. But the moral drama of our lives isn’t just about oppression. We’re dealing with all sorts of things, from forgiveness to mercy to shame to guilt to joy to truth to peace to reconciliation. And hitting mercy with a hammer just isn’t a good idea. You’ll break it.

Consider an obvious example: how the social justice movement struggles with the issue of forgiveness. With the pervasiveness of what has been called “cancel culture,” can the canceled ever be forgiven? What about problematic allies? What if someone’s moral performance for the cause is less than perfect? The social justice movement struggles here with the issues of mercy, grace, forgiveness, and reconciliation. The reason for this is that justice is a hammer, and while a hammer is an excellent tool for nails, it is not so great with other moral tasks. Forgiveness is a different problem than injustice. You need different tools. The moral drama of life isn’t putting up a swing set in the backyard, easily tackled with the single tool enclosed in the box; it’s building an entire house. Moral life is cement work, brick laying, carpentry, plumbing, electrical, roofing, painting, and so on. You need more than a hammer.
So here is one reason we need to keep the moral layer connected to the narrative and symbolic layer. Moral and political life is complicated and nuanced and that requires a fuller, thicker, and and richer narrative and symbolic foundation. Without this foundation, moral life becomes crude, reductive, agonistic, and incoherent.  

Let's now go one layer deeper. What happens when the moral layer looses contact with the ontological layer, the layer of the Real?

I'll point out two things.

First, as I've repeatedly pointed out over the years, the Judeo-Christian moral vision demands a metaphysics of hope. For two reasons. First, without hope the moral drama of our lives, our small efforts to make the world a better place, will succumb to despair, rage, cynicism, hate, burnout, compassion fatigue, and the violence motivated by what John Howard Yoder called "revolutionary impatience." If the moral arch of history doesn't, ontologically, bend toward justice, then it will be impossible to maintain the Judeo-Christian moral vision of love and justice in a committed, persevering, and joy-filled way. And the critical point to underline here is that hope isn't a moral commitment. Nor is it a symbolic one. Hope is an ontological issue. What sustains the Judeo-Christian moral vision of love and justice is its connection to the Real.

Secondly, the actual content of the Judeo-Christian moral vision is subject to drift, corruption, or replacement. There are anti-humanistic ethics afoot in the world. The liberal humanism of the West, grounded in Judeo-Christian narrative and ontology, is faltering. 

Now, it might be countered here that some of this faltering is due to Christians themselves, their instrumental embrace of authoritarianism and fascism to accomplish short-term political and cultural goals. In response, I'd simply point to Tom Holland's argument in Dominion that these liberal and humanistic criticisms of authoritarianism and fascism are, themselves, rooted in the Judeo-Christian tradition. Which means that this conflict will necessarily boil down to ontology. That is, what is the true and real moral vision of Jesus of Nazareth? Phrased differently, the task of resistance, as ontological critique, is prophetic in nature. Who--really, truly--speaks for the Lord? 

Of course, a liberal humanist might want to criticize Christian nationalism from the outside, in purely secular terms. To that person I'd simply say, "Best of luck!" For a few reasons, but an obvious one is that the Christian fascists, as Christians, believe themselves to be standing on the Real. They're wrong, in my estimation, but they are making ontological claims. The secular liberal humanist, by contrast, is a nihilist. That is to say, the secular liberal humanist--as a pluralistic post-modernist--is unable to defend their moral vision is either real or true. Again, the liberal humanist has cut themselves off from the existential and ontological layers. Their moral vision rests on air. And in a debate between a nihilist and a ontologist the ontologist is going to win every time. In short, if you want to criticize the Christian fascist you're going to have to do so on ontological grounds. You must become a prophet. Which means you have to connect your moral vision to the ontological layer.

Planting Gardens in Babylon: On How to Lose an Election

I'm writing this post on September 25. Yesterday, September 24, I delivered the chapel talk at Bushnell University, which also served as the keynote address for a gathering hosted by Bushnell. The title of our conversation and my keynote was "Faithful Engagement: Navigating Anxiety in a Polarized Election." Instead of posting this three months out, like most of my posts (which would have had this post appearing in late December) I've decided to drop it here, the first post after the election.

Given that it's September I don't know what we're waking up to today, November 6th. It's possible we don't know who won, that votes are still being counted or that the outcome is being contested or questioned. But maybe the winner is clear and a concession speech has been offered.

Regardless, I think it's safe to assume that the nation is feeling pretty fragile this morning, either anxiously awaiting a final verdict or half the country feeling intense dismay. Which brings me back to my Bushnell talk.

I framed my talk yesterday around two sermons I gave at my church, Freedom Fellowship, in 2016 and 2020. Freedom meets on Wednesdays, which means, like today, we always gather the day after elections. On both of those Wednesdays in 2016 and 2020 I was the one, just because of luck, scheduled to give the lesson. In 2016, after Trump had defeated Clinton, all my Democrat friends were dismayed and shell-shocked. Seeing this, I delivered a sermon entitled "How to Lose an Election." Four years later, my Republican friends were dismayed when Trump lost to Biden. And so, I delivered the exact same sermon for second time: "How to Lose an Election."

I told those stories at Bushnell to set up a conversation about how to deal with anxiety during a polarized election. Basically, as Christians, we need to learn how to lose elections. And while I don't know who won or lost as I write this, some of us are feeling anger, fear, and dismay today.

So, how do you lose an election?

In my Bushnell talk, one of the points I made comes from Jeremiah 29. Some of the Israelites have returned home from their Babylonian exile. But many remain behind in Babylon. These write to the prophet Jeremiah asking if they should come home. But Jeremiah writes back to say, no, you should stay in Babylon. And not just stay, to multiply and thrive:

Thus says the Lord of hosts, the God of Israel, to all the exiles whom I have sent into exile from Jerusalem to Babylon: Build houses and live in them; plant gardens and eat what they produce. Take wives and have sons and daughters; take wives for your sons, and give your daughters in marriage, that they may bear sons and daughters; multiply there, and do not decrease. But seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile, and pray to the Lord on its behalf, for in its welfare you will find your welfare. 

Seek the welfare of the city, for it its welfare you will find your welfare. Crucially, the Israelites remain in Babylon as a marginalized, disenfranchised, exilic people. They do not control Babylon, nor will they ever control Babylon. Political power is not in their hands. And yet, there is work to do! Seek the welfare of the city.

And let's be clear on this point, this is Babylon we are talking about. Babylon, the epitome of wickedness, oppression, injustice, violence, and evil in Biblical history and imagination. The point here is that the People of God thrive in places of political marginalization. The People of God thrive in Babylon. So there's no excuse for us not to thrive, even if we lost the election. No matter the outcome today, there is good, creative, generative, and beautiful work to do.

How do you lose an election? It's simple.

You plant gardens in Babylon.

Nature, Grace, and Virtue: Part 3, Doxological Recognition

As I described in the last post, if we understand that nature is grounded in God then we need not posit some hard contrast between "natural" versus "supernatural" virtue. As described by Maximus the Confessor, God is the ground of all virtue. Consequently, wherever we find kindness and goodness we are beholding the sacred aspect of creation, which necessarily exists in every human person, ascending to God.

What, then, does the spiritual life add to our growth in virtue?

The main difference, I would argue, between virtue found among believers and non-believers is doxological. When we come to understand the Source of our kindness and goodness we can give thanks and praise. To be sure, people can manifest virtue without thanksgiving, but without doxological recognition the Source and Goal of our virtue goes unrecognized. There are, for example, many kind and generous people in the world. But without doxological recognition they assume that they are the source of their own virtue, that their kindness and generosity are personality traits, natural endowments, they just happen to possess. In addition, these virtues are not intentionally directed toward their true Home. This doesn't make people any less generous or kind, but this lack of doxological recognition limits the developmental potential of the virtues we "naturally" possess.

This, then, is what we mean when we say "grace perfects nature." Through doxological recognition, knowing where our virtue comes from and where it is going, we participate with God's Spirit in the developmental maturation of our character. Grace leads our nature toward its fulfillment. Knowing our Source and End we gain navigational clarity and influence over our lives. No longer do the virtues appear within our character as genetic happenstance, the random luck of being born with a certain personality trait. Through doxological recognition we come to recognize our capacities for kindness and love as the accompaniment of God, the inner Voice within our hearts calling us Home.   

Like wild flowers, the virtues grow all around us. And like wild flowers, we are delighted whenever and wherever we encounter them. Kindness and goodness in the world are a blessing. They are windows into heaven. But we can do more than delight in these encounters of sporadic beauty. We can give thanks. We can recognize the Source of goodness in the world and come to participate more deeply in widening its influence. To adopt a doxological posture toward virtue, to know its Beginning and its End, is to participate more fully in the Grace that calls all beautiful things back to Itself.

The Case Against the Sexual Revolution: Part 13, There is More to Harm than Guilt

Why am I, someone with progressive Christian and political beliefs, devoting so much time reflecting on Louise Perry's book The Case Against the Sexual Revolution? 

The main reason is that, as regular readers know, I've come to identify myself as "post-progressive." And one of the reasons I've moved into this new space, as I've shared, is a dissatisfaction with the progressive Christian conversation about sex. Sharply stated, progressive Christianity doesn't have anything to say about sex beyond sacralizing the reigning cultural consensus of guilt-free sex with the minimum ethical standard of mutual consent. 

Broadly speaking, progressive Christians have tried to minimize the guilt associated with sex by lowering the stakes of sex. If sex us just "fun," no big deal, then hooking up is nothing to be ashamed of. In fact, you're encouraged to do this. 

As a post-progressive, I'm not interested in making anyone feel guilty for having sex. I think just about all of my college students are having sex, and I don't have a judgmental bone in my body about any of that. But as a post-progressive, I do think that sex is pretty high stakes, and that lowering its stakes is a recipe for a lot of hurt. So while I don't judge my students, I do worry about them. 

What do I mean by sex being "high stakes"? 

The progressive moral code is basically "do no harm." If no one is being hurt, then no one should have any moral objection. This includes sex. If everyone is consenting in the bedroom you can keep your nose out of my business. 

But here's my question: Does consent capture everything we mean by harm when it comes to sex? This is the question I think The Case Against the Sexual Revolution gets on our radar screen, a deeper consideration of what may or may not be harmful when it comes to sex. Simply put, more than guilt is at stake in sex, and yet guilt is just about the only thing progressive Christians seem interested in talking about (likely as a reactive posture toward evangelical purity culture). I'm not interested in making anyone feel guilty about sex, but I am concerned about harms that aren't captured by consent. I think #MeToo brought a lot of those harms into the light.

And consider this question that wasn't captured by #MeToo. Imagine a young man in a relationship with a young woman. She very much has a romantic crush on him, is falling in love with him. For his part, he likes this young woman, considers her a good friend. And being a young male, he does entertain thoughts of having sex with her. And she's willing. She'd give consent. But the young man doesn't love her. So, an ethical question: Should he have sex with her? How do you calculate the harm he'll do to her by having sex with her, knowing that, in the end, it's "just sex" for him but so much more for her? Having sex will cause her to fall more deeply in love, and he knows he's going to walk away. So, should he have sex with her? What choice causes more or less harm?

I think you could make a pretty good ethical case that the young man will do more harm if he has sex with the young woman. I'd argue that the ethical thing to do--Could we say the chivalrous and noble thing to do?--would be to not have sex with her. Refusing sex might be painful to her, but that pain would be much less than the harm he'd do to her emotionally if they started a "friends with benefits" relationship knowing that this sexual intimacy will make her fall ever more deeply in love with him. 

This is the sort of thing I mean by describing sex as "high stakes." Like it or not, sex is associated with love and intimacy. Which makes the "do no harm" calculus so much more weighty and complicated. And it raises the question: Where in our culture are we acquiring the virtues necessary to help us navigate this complexity? I just don't see it.

Listen, I appreciate the progressive concern about guilt. But progressive Christians need to start pushing beyond guilt to discuss other sorts of harm. Because those harms are real. Progressive Christians need to snap out of their obsessive orbiting of evangelical purity culture, always playing the reactive moon to the evangelical sun. And that's what I like about  Louise Perry's The Case Against the Sexual Revolution, that even if you disagree with her, she spotlights harms that aren't typically talked about by liberals and progressives. Perry's book raises the stakes on sex in ways I think are worth considering. For example, from her chapter "Loveless Sex Is Not Empowering" Perry makes some observations and then asks some questions:
...Today's young women are typically unaware that men are, in general, much better suited to emotionless sex and find it much easier to regard their sexual partners as disposable. Ignorant of this fact, women can all too easily fail to recognise that being desired is not at all the same thing as being held in high esteem. It isn't nice to think of oneself as disposable or to acknowledge that other people view you that way. Often, it's easier to turn away from any acknowledgement of what is really going on, at least temporarily. I've spoken to a lot of women who participated in hook-up culture when they were young and only years later came to realise just how unhappy it made them. I've yet to meet anyone who has travelled the same emotional journey, but in the opposite direction.

If you're a woman who's had casual sexual relationships with men in the past, you might try answering the following questions as honestly as you can: 
  1. Did you consider your virginity to be an embarrassing burden you wanted to be rid of? 
  2. Do you ever feel disgusted when you think about consensual sexual experiences you've had in the past?
  3. Have you ever become emotionally attached to a casual sexual partner and concealed this attachment from him? 
  4. Have you ever done something sexually that you found painful or unpleasant and concealed this discomfort from your partner, either during sex or afterward? 
If you answer "no" to all of these questions, your high sociosexuality and good luck have allowed you to navigate successfully a treacherous sexual marketplace. But if you answer "yes" to any of them, you are entitled to feel angry at a sexual culture that set you up to fail.

On Meaning in Life: Part 4, Mattering Matters Most

So, meaning in life is a cord of three strands. Coherence. Purpose. Mattering.

And yet, before moving on, a pause to discuss the relative importance of these three aspects of meaning. Specifically, are they equally important in achieving meaning in life?

A recent study done in 2020 found that, of the three strands of meaning in life, it was mattering that mattered the most. In evaluating the relative roles of coherence, purpose and mattering in predicting meaning in life (MIL) the researchers concluded:

The finding that sense of mattering, rather than coherence or purpose, emerged consistently as the strongest precursor of MIL judgments seems especially important given that both coherence and purpose have been long associated with MIL, and in some cases, seen as coterminous with MIL. By contrast, sense of mattering has been relatively neglected up to now within the psychological literature on MIL. Our results therefore support calls to supplement the emphasis on coherence or purpose in the psychological literature on meaning with a much stronger focus on understanding how people come to develop and maintain a sense of mattering in their lives, and the consequences of doing so or otherwise.
It's important to note that the study observed both religious and non-religious routes to mattering. A key issue for non-religious mattering seems to be the issue of impact, legacy, and generativity. That is, do I judge that my life is "making a difference"? Some people, who are fortunate enough to have meaningful work, will likely find answering the question of mattering to be fairly easy, with little need for recourse to metaphysics. But such answers tend to make mattering the luck of the educated, talented, and elite. Most of the word will struggle to find their work so life-giving. For most of us, mattering is going to be harder to locate.

But even for those who have meaningful lives due to work, along with ample leisure time, the situation remains precarious. There's a reason why people jumped out of windows to their death during the Great Depression. As I recount in Hunting Magic Eels, I once helped treat a man in an inpatient hospital who had tried to commit suicide. The man worked as an emergency medical responder. His job was, quite literally, saving lives. And as you might expect, he found that work deeply meaningful. He mattered. 

But the man had suffered a debilitating back injury. Suddenly, he could no longer do his job and was relegated to a desk. Soon he became depressed and then tried to kill himself. 

My point in telling that story from Hunting Magic Eels is that non-religious mattering is provisional and fragile. Yes, mattering is easy if you have fulfilling, purposeful work. But that's not really when we need mattering. We need mattering when that man needed mattering, which is when he lost his job and began to question the significance of his life. We don't need contingent mattering, conditional mattering. We need stable, durable, unconditional mattering. 

The issue, then, isn't that you matter. Lots of people can say their life matters. 

The critical question is when you matter. 

Pascal's PensƩes: Week 17, At Home in the Universe?

201.

The eternal silence of these infinite spaces fills me with dread.

///

Here we have one of Pascal's most famous lines.

Are we at home in the universe? Or are we an accident?

Many non-theists turn to life in the cosmos to instill and inspire wonder and awe, the surest materialistic route to something akin to religious transcendence. Carl Sagan was famous for making this move. Given the long cosmic odds, and all the necessary fine-tuning of the physical constants of the universe, it's really quite remarkable, even miraculous, that we find ourselves existing on this Pale Blue Dot. 

And as I point out in Hunting Magic Eels, these facts about our existence, and the energy of its attendant wonder, can be leveraged into a moral response, a materialistic warrant for loving and caring for life and the world we inhabit. Life is so very precious and rare, we must cherish and care for it.

Amen. But as I go on to point out in Hunting Magic Eels, and as Pascal points out above, our winning the cosmic lottery can cut both ways. There's a difference between feeling grateful versus feeling lucky. A difference between feeling at home in the universe and feeling liked you dodged a cosmic bullet to the head. As the scientists remind us, we're all quite fortunate and lucky to be here. But feeling lucky for life is different from feeling grateful. Gratitude is a social emotion, the response we feel when we've been given a gift. And where there is a gift, there is a gift-giver. As I say in the book, you can't feel grateful for life and creation and be an atheist, not emotionally. Being awed at the cosmic odds is different from saying "Thank you."

As I describe in Hunting Magic Eels, the psychological and existential difference between luck and grace (grace is the same word as gift in the New Testament) is illustrated in how feeling lucky, while able to be leveraged positively, also has the nagging and chronic vulnerability of slipping into despair and nihilism. This is Pascal's point. Feeling lucky is not too far from feeling like an accident, even a mistake, that the universe didn't want us, need us, and, regardless, will soon be rid of us. As the great atheist Jean-Paul Sartre put it, "Every existing thing is born without reason, prolongs itself out of weakness and dies by chance." Suck on that Carl Sagan.

Experiencing your life and creation as a gift, however, protects us from this nihilistic pit. Life is more than luck. You were meant to be here. Life is a gift. Existence is graced. A grace that provides a sturdier platform for both mental health and love than chance and cosmic rolls of the dice.

So look around, in wonder and awe, and say, "Thank you."

The Gospel According to The Lord of the Rings: Week 50, A Small Surprising Providence

The Rohirrim ride into battle, and the Witch-King withdraws from the gates of Gondor. This is Theoden's great moment of glory, as the tide of the battle turns.

But the Witch-King returns to the fight, now mounted upon a great, winged creature. And the Lord of the Nazgƻl deals Theoden a mortal blow.

And in that moment of despair, two of the most unlikely warriors step forward to avenge their fallen king. Merry, Hobbit of the Shire, and Ɖowyn, lady and shieldmaiden of Rohan. Refusing to be left behind, Ɖowyn had rode into battle disguised as a man.  

Assuming Ɖowyn to be a man, the Lord of the NazgĆ»l taunts her, saying "No living man can hinder me!" For long ago Glorfindel had made a prophecy concerning him: "Not by the hand of man will he fall." Hearing these words, Ɖowyn reveals herself, "But no living man am I! You look upon a woman."

The Witch-King sets his monstrous steed upon Ɖowyn. She strikes, severing its head. The Witch-King rises from the dead beast, advances, and brings a crushing blow down upon Ɖowyn's shield, shattering it and breaking her arm. The fight seems over. And then, quite forgotten, Merry attacks, cutting the sinews of the NazgĆ»l's knee. The blow is enough to stagger the Witch-King. Seeing her moment, Ɖowyn drives her sword through the invisible face, killing the Black Captain.

After the death of ThĆ©oden on the field of battle, the narrative will return to linger upon Merry's sword, the sword which dealt the surprising, unlikely blow to the Witch-King. This blade was, it will be recalled, one of the swords that Tom Bombadil gave Merry, Sam, and Pippin from the Barrow-downs. It was a sword forged long ago by the Men of Westernesse, forged for their battles with the same sorcerer king of Angmar. And here, in the Battle of the Pelnennor Fields, the ancient blade fulfills its destiny, finally finding its enemy, after long centuries and many twists and turns, in a blow struck by the most unlikely of people. 

Two themes mix together in the defeat of the Witch-King, surprise and providence. Providence in how we discern something more than chance at work in finding a woman standing before the Witch-King and a sword of Westernesse close at hand. And yet, when we invoke providence, we tend to think of something inexorable and predictable. But the death of the Witch-King was anything put predictable. He certainly didn't see it coming. We are startled and surprised. So much so, it is hard not to see providence as great fortune or luck.

And much of this effect is due to the smallness of the two critical actors. A woman and a hobbit in the midst of a raging battle, standing against the greatest power of Mordor, second only to Sauron himself. But on the Fields of Pelnennor the weak will defeat the strong. It is a small, surprising providence.   

I write this post a week before Christmas. And the theme of a small surprising providence seems very apt for the season. The comparison isn't perfect, but one sees a bit of Mary in Ɖowyn, a woman bringing doom to the Witch-King. But what is very clear is that the story of Christmas is a bit of a surprise in its smallness. The great tide of history turns upon small people making small choices. Just like the events on the Fields of Pelnennor, the Nativity story is filled with portents and prophecies, the history ancient and full of lore. The Hand of Providence is as work. 

But still, a providence so small and surprising. 

The Gospel According to The Lord of the Rings: Week 43, Saved By Grace or Luck?

Before turning our attention back to Frodo and Sam in Book 4, one last note about the "deep narrative" of the story appearing with the Company.

After the fall of Isengard, Gandalf takes with him the palantĆ­r, the round crystal ball Saruman was using to communicate with Sauron.

For some reason, the palantĆ­r holds an allure for Pippin, who is drawn to it in way that serves as an allegory of desire and sin. In the night, Pippin steals the palantĆ­r from Gandalf and looks into it.

Looking into the palantĆ­r Pippin comes face to face with Sauron, who questions him. Pippin cries out and awakens Gandalf.

Upon learning what Pippin has done Gandalf examines Pippin and finds that no damage has been done to him. Relieved, he shares this with Pippin:

But mark this! You have been saved, and all your friends too, mainly by good fortune, as it is called.

Is Pippin saved by grace or by luck? Gandalf seems to hint that what we call luck might actually be grace. We could be misdescribing our lives. There's a joke I've been telling for years. When something fortuitous happens, I'll say, "We were lucky, or it was providential, depending upon your metaphysic."

Not a real knee slapper of a joke. But it illustrates Gandalf's point. Is your life a story of grace or luck? Is someone watching out for us or is it all just random chance? It reminds me of M. Night Shyamalan's movie Signs. In the movie you may recall Mel Gibson's character is a priest struggling with faith, and at the start of the movie he shares this:

People break down into two groups. When they experience something lucky, group number one sees it as more than luck, more than coincidence. They see it as a sign, evidence, that there is someone up there, watching out for them. Group number two sees it as just pure luck. Just a happy turn of chance...deep down, they feel that whatever happens, they're on their own. And that fills them with fear. Yeah, there are those people. But there's a whole lot of people in group number one...they're looking at a miracle. And deep down, they feel that whatever's going to happen, there will be someone there to help them. And that fills them with hope. See what you have to ask yourself is what kind of person are you? Are you the kind that sees signs, that sees miracles? Or do you believe that people just get lucky?

The Teleological Gaze: Part 2, Manipulation and Meaninglessness

As noted in the last post, causal stories and teleological stories are very different. In fact, this is one way to distinguish science from religion. Science tells a causal story and faith tells a teleological story.

Prior to the Enlightenment, the stories we told about nature and ourselves were teleological. Existence had purpose. And this wasn't just the case in the realm of religion. Pre-Enlightenment science was teleological. The world moved and changed as the objects and creatures in the world sought their proper goals and ends. As Aristotle taught in his physics that governed the Western world, the best way to understand why things are the way they are is to understand what purpose they were designed to serve.

This teleological gaze was killed off by the Enlightenment and the rise of modern science. You could argue that this teleological-to-causal shift was the fundamental change that gave rise to the modern world, and represents the critical imaginative difference between "science" and "religion."

Darwinian evolution is Exhibit A of the teleological-to-causal shift. According to a teleological account of biological life, the various evidences of "design" we found in nature pointed toward purposes, toward a telos. This "fit" between design and purpose was evidence of a divine intelligence or rationality (logos).

But where teleology looked forward toward a telos--a goal, reason, end, or purpose--the story Darwin told looked backwards at antecedent causes. Darwin pointed out that "design" could be produced through dumb and random processes. Genetic variation coupled with natural selection ("survival of the fittest") could mold phenotypes over time, fitting them to ecosystems and thereby creating the illusion of "design." Under the teleological gaze, cats have claws so they can catch mice and humans have opposable thumbs so we can make tools. But after Darwin, these teleological accounts were rejected. No purpose or telos drove the evolution of claws or thumbs. These arose through random genetic variation and the culling of natural selection.

Obviously, a causal approach to the natural world has yielded great fruits. Our capacity to manipulate the causal fabric of the world has given us enormous technological power. But the demise of the teleological hasn't come without a price. Specifically, we've traded meaning for manipulation.

The causal gaze gives us the ability to manipulate the physical universe, but at the cost of meaning. The causal gaze strips existence of purpose. Again, Darwin is a good illustration here. Why do we exist? Because of dumb, random physical processes. There's no "reason" behind our existence beyond luck, and we might just as well have not existed. In short, the causal gaze gives us great technological power but its pricetag is nihilism. We have material mastery but spiritual incompetence.

As the atheist and Noble Prize-winning physicist Steven Weinberg summed up, "The more the universe seems comprehensible, the more it also seems pointless."

The Gospel According to the Lord of the Rings: Week 3, A Lower Anthropology

Last week we talked about one of two contrasts Fleming Rutledge makes between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. That contrast was between chance and providence. In The Hobbit, Bilbo's fate seems to be driven by good fortune. In The Lord of the Rings that element of chance drops out almost completely. In The Lord of the Rings there is "something else at work" in the background, and Rutledge traces this thread as the deep theological narrative of the book.

The second contrast Rutledge makes is related to the first and has to do with an anthropological contrast.

Theological anthropology, our view of human persons, is an interesting area of reflection in my discipline of psychology. How capable are people in self-actualizing? Is self-help realistic or doomed? Are we innately good or totally depraved? And on and on.

Broadly, we can classify anthropological theories as being either higher or lower, more optimistic versus more pessimistic. A higher anthropology tends to be optimistic about human nature and capacities. At root, we're both good and capable. Just give us room to grow! A lower anthropology, by contrast, is pessimistic about human nature. Humans are fallible, sinful, and weak.

With that background, similar to last week's observations, Rutledge makes a contrast between a higher anthropology in The Hobbit versus a lower anthropology in The Lord of the Rings. Specifically, Rutledge cites a passage after Bilbo saves his companions from the giant spiders in Mirkwood:
...somehow the killing of the giant spider, all alone by himself in the dark without the help of the wizard or the dwarves or of anyone else, made a great difference to Mr. Baggins. He felt himself a different person, and much fiercer and bolder in spite of an empty stomach.
There's a humanistic aspect to this passage. Hero faces challenge. Hero rises to challenge. Hero grows and self-actualizes. This is an optimistic anthropology. It's the anthropology of self-help and the meritocracy. 

But Rutledge observes something about this passage in The Hobbit: "I emphasize this passage because it is so striking that there isn't anything like it in The Lord of the Rings." And what sets it apart are the words "all alone by himself." No character does anything in The Lord of the Rings "all alone by himself."

Now, it could be argued that Rutledge puts too much on this one passage. Last week in the comments JD Walters pointed to a different passage toward the end of The Hobbit, Gandalf speaking to Bilbo:
You don’t really suppose do you that all your adventures and escapes were managed by mere luck? Just for your sole benefit? You’re a very fine person, Mr. Baggins, and I’m quite fond of you. But you are really just a little fellow, in a wide world after all!
I think that's quite a good point that mitigates against Rutledge's hard contrast between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings.

For my part, I'd split the different between Rutledge and JD's comment that "There is certainly not a switch from events in The Hobbit happening due to chance and those in LOTR happening due to purpose. Tolkien's messaging is consistent in both." Because of his Catholic faith, I think Tolkien, in his own mind, held a consistent vision across the two books. That said, I do think the anthropology dramatized in the narrative of The Hobbit is more optimistic, necessitating the expository correction by Gandalf at the end. That is, what might have been in Tolkien's head wasn't really portrayed in the story, and had to get dropped in like a deus ex machina at the end. In The Lord of the Rings, by contrast, the lower anthropology Gandalf speaks of in The Hobbit is deeply woven into the narrative. This lower anthropology isn't found through a "correction" delivered in a speech, since it is so vividly displayed and dramatized in a way it just isn't in The Hobbit. Rutledge is right that nothing like the phrase "all alone by himself" occurs in The Lord of the Rings, a passage that Tolkien seems keen to "take back" at the end of the Hobbit. All that to say, the pessimistic note sounded at the end of The Hobbit is right there at the start of The Lord of the Rings.

More on this anthropological aspect of The Lord of the Rings next week.  

The Gospel According to The Lord of the Rings: Week 2, "Something Else at Work"

It might seem strange to hear Fleming Rutledge say that The Lord of the Rings is a book about God. Because on the surface at least, Middle Earth is godless and irreligious. The world isn't Christian, but neither is it pagan. There are no references to deities. There is no worship, no religious rites, rituals, or sacrifices. No prayers or petitions to God or gods.

To be sure, the metaphysics of Middle earth are explored in The Silmarillion. But the drama of The Lord of the Rings takes place largely within a metaphysical vacuum. And that vacuum, says Rutledge, creates a blank canvas upon which we might detect the actions of God.

One way to see this, for Rutledge, is to contrast the metaphysics of The Hobbit with The Lord of the Rings. And it's a good place to start this series as The Hobbit functions as the prequel to The Lord of the Rings.

Two things strike you about the metaphysics of The Hobbit in contrast to The Lord of the Rings. I'll talk about the first contrast this week and the second contrast next week.

The first contrast is the emphasis on chance and luck in The Hobbit in contrast to The Lord of the Rings. Consider how Bilbo finds the Ring in The Hobbit. He's crawling around in the dark and by chance puts his hand on top of the Ring. Nothing more is said about this discovery from a metaphysical perspective. Thus, the reader is lead to believe that this discovery is simply good fortune, a lucky break. A significant bit of fortune, no doubt, but a chance happening nonetheless. And we find similar examples of Bilbo's good fortune and luck throughout his adventures in The Hobbit.

But a metaphysical change occurs in the Lord of the Rings. Fortune and luck give way to a guiding providence. Rutledge highlights this change in the first chapter of The Lord of the Rings "The Shadow of the Past" when Gandalf is sharing with Frodo the history of the Ring and Bilbo's discovery of it:
"There was more than one power at work, Frodo. The Ring was trying to get back to its master...It abandoned Gollum. Only to be picked up by the most unlikely person imaginable: Bilbo from the Shire!

"Behind that there was something else at work, beyond any design of the Ring-maker [the Dark Lord, Sauron]. I can put it no plainer than by saying that Bilbo was meant to find the Ring, and not by its maker. In which case you were also meant to have it."
The emphases are in the original. Bilbo was meant to find the Ring, and Frodo was meant to have it. But how and why? Because, as Gandalf says, there was "something else at work," a mysterious, unnamed Power in the background working to thwart the power of Evil.

This reference to a background Power working to thwart Evil can be highlighted because of the metaphysical vacuum in The Lord of the Rings. We can see this Power at work because the heavens are empty in The Lord of the Rings. If the supernatural realm was busy and buzzing in The Lord of the Ring we'd miss the subtle acts--the still, small voice--of this background Power.

The "story about God" Rutledge finds in The Lord of the Rings is the drama of the providential working of this background Power. She calls it the "deep narrative" of The Lord of the Rings, and it provides a stark theological contrast with The Hobbit.

In The Hobbit, Bilbo finds the Ring by chance.

In The Lord of the Rings, Bilbo was meant to find it.

Jesus Was a Refugee

As the principalities and powers continue to display inhospitality to the refugees of the world, this Advent season I am reminded of this poem: "The Flight in the Desert" by Brother Antoninus:


The last settlement scraggled out with a barbed wire fence
And fell from sight. They crossed coyote country:
Mesquite, sage, the bunchgrass knotted in patches;
And there the prairie dog yapped in the valley;
And on the high plateau the short-armed badger
Delved his clay. But beyond that the desert,
Raw, unslakable, its perjured dominion wholly contained
In the sun's remorseless mandate, where the dim trail
Died ahead in the watery horizon: God knows where.

And there the failures: skull of the ox,
Where the animal terror trembled on in the hollowed eyes;
The catastrophic wheel, split, sandbedded;
And the sad jawbone of a horse. These the denials
Of the retributive tribes, fiercer than pestilence,
Whose scrupulous realm this was.

Only the burro took no notice: the forefoot
Placed with the nice particularity of one
To who the evil of the day is wholly sufficient.
Even the jocular ears marked time,
But they, the man and the anxious woman,
Who stared pinch-eyed into the settling sun,
They went forward into its denseness
All apprehensive, and would many a time have turned
But for what they carried. That brought them on,
In the gritty blanket they bore the world's great risk,
And knew it; and kept it covered, near to the blind heart,
That hugs in a bad hour its sweetest need,
Possessed against the drawn night
That comes now, over the dead arroyos,
Cold and acrid and black.

This was the first of his goings forth into the wilderness of the world.
There was much to follow: much of portent, much of dread.
But what was so meek then and so mere, so slight and strengthless,
(Too tender, almost, to be touched)--what they nervously guarded
Guarded them. As we, each day, from the lifted chalice,
That strengthless Bread the mildest tongue subsumes,
To be taken out in the blatant kingdom,
Where Herod sweats, and his deft henchmen
Riffle the tabloids--that keeps us.

Over the campfire the desert moon
Slivers the west, too chaste and cleanly
To mean hard luck. The man rattles the skillet
To take the raw edge off the silence;
The woman lifts up her heart; the Infant
Knuckles the generous breast, and feeds.

The Paradoxes of Progressive Political Theology: How Did Progressives Come to Think They Were Anabaptists?

Let me tell you the story about how many progressive Christians came to think they were Anabaptists.

(I'm mainly talking about post-evangelical progressives rather than traditional mainline progressives.)

To recap, I've made the argument that many progressive Christians believe they are Anabaptists when, in fact, they are Niebuhrians. This truth was exposed with the election of Donald Trump. The rise of Trump has politically energized progressive Christians in ways that are hard to reconcile with Anabaptist theology and practice. Again, this is no judgment of Anabaptist theology or of all the political activism of progressive Christians. Not at all. This is just a description of the disjoint between political theology and political praxis.

Most progressive Christians want to be politically engaged. Very much so. Especially with Donald Trump in office. But Anabaptist theology doesn't provide great theological scaffolding for much of that political activism. Thus my advice: Seek out and embrace a political theology that provides better theological support. To my eye, I think that theology is Niebuhr's Christian realism.

But that raises a different question. Why did so many progressive Christians come to embrace Anabaptist theology in the first place?

That's the story I want to tell you.

The story starts in 2003, with George W. Bush and the invasion of Iraq. Many progressive Christians mobilized against that war. At the time social media was just exploding. Blogging was in its Golden Age. Twitter would show up in 2006, just in time for the 2007-2008 Presidential campaign where we debated the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, torture, and Guantanamo Bay.

As these debates raged on social media, Anabaptist theology, with it's criticisms of nationalism and war, became a powerful theological tool in the hands of progressive Christians to level indictments at the Bush administration.

In addition, emergent and post-evangelical expressions of Christianity were going strong. Many disaffected and disillusioned evangelicals were looking around for theological positions that critiqued how evangelicalism had been co-opted by politics. With its strong criticisms of Constantinianism, Anabaptist theology also fit that bill.  

And so it was during these years that many progressive Christians, in using Anabaptist theology so effectively to critique the Bush administration and the politicization of evangelicalism, convinced themselves that they were Anabaptists.

But they weren't Anabaptists, not really.

Why weren't progressives Anabaptists? Two reasons.

First, there's more to Anabaptist theology than its peace witness. Anabaptist theology also espouses a robust ecclesiology, the church as the locus of life and political witness. This aspect of Anabaptist theology doesn't sit well with many progressive Christians, who would rather work as political activists than invest in the daily life of a local church. To be sure, many post-evangelical progressive Christians harbor nostalgia for the local church, memories of hymn sings, youth camps, Vacation Bible School and pot luck casseroles. But at the end of the day, progressive Christians tend to think calling Congress, community organizing, and marching in protests are the best ways to make the kingdom come on earth as it is in heaven.

Second, the robust ecclesiology of Anabaptist thought and practice works with a strong church vs. world distinction. This contrast has been famously captured by Stanley Hauerwas: "The first task of the church is not to make the world more just but to make the world the world." In Anabaptist thought the church is set apart from the world, its goal to be a witness to the Powers by making a stark contrast between the kingdom of God and Babylon.

That negative view of the world has never sat well with progressives who, being liberals, tend to have a very favorable view of the world, a view which sits behind their very open, inclusive, cosmopolitan, non-judgmental social ethic. Progressives want to embrace the world, they don't want to create a community that highlights the darkness and depravity of the world. For many post-evangelical progressives, a negative view of the world smacks of the judgementalism they are fleeing from.

In short, during the Bush years progressives used parts of Anabaptist theology to great effect. Progressive Christians denounced the evils of war, empire, nationalism, and Constantinian Christianity. Progressive Christians were so effective in this critique that they started to think they actually were Anabaptists. But progressive Christians never really were Anabaptists. They were post-evangelicals who became Democrats.

Edging Toward Enchantment: Prayer as Hallowing

As I mentioned in the last post, due to disenchantment meaning and significance are harder in this secular age. This creates, in the words of Charles Taylor, a "terrible flatness in the everyday."

Earlier in this series I described how we can edge back toward enchantment by giving life a sacred texture. We do this by hallowing, giving the flatness of daily life some sacred "weight."

Practices like prayer help us here. Prayer gives life sacred weight and texture.

As I've written about before, one of my favorite parts of Sara Miles' memoir Take This Bread is how, after she starts a food pantry at her church St. Gregory, she gets pulled into a ministry of prayer, this despite all her doubts and skepticism about prayer:
The atmosphere of St. Gregory's drew people in: They came looking for something to eat, but often, like the woman seeking peace, or like me, they really wanted far more. I'd be lifting a box, in the noise and bustle, and someone would come up to me--a grieving mom, a lonely immigrant, a sick man, or any of the many varieties of crazy people who hovered around the pantry. "Will you pray for me?" they'd ask.

So I took a deep breath and began praying with anyone who asked...I'd get people such as Ed, a filthy white guy with long hair who'd frequently flop down on the curb, begging for help. One of our most insane and drug-addicted visitors, he'd sob and rant, in no particular sequence...I'd sit down on the sidewalk with him and wipe his nose. "Oh God," he'd say, "I can't go on like this. Help me, help me." I was sort of fond of Ed, despite his hysteria, so I'd pat his stringy arm and murmur until he calmed down a bit, then fetch him a snack, make the sign of the cross on his dirty forehead, and send him on his way with a few bags of food...

"It seems really hokey sometimes," I said to Lynn.

"I know," said Lynn. "But big deal. You just have to be there."

So I'd sit down next to people and let them talk or cry; I'd listen and put my hands on them; at some point, I'd pray aloud, without really knowing where the words were coming from. It felt homey, not mysterious. But it usually made me cry, too.
I like these passages in the book because they mirror my own experience. As a doubting and disenchanted Christian I struggle a lot with prayer. But when you start to engage with people on the margins you are inexorably drawn into the experience of prayer. And what you begin to appreciate is how prayer is a practice of hallowing.

Imagine someone comes to you and shares a great burden. They share loss, failure, despair, fear, brokenness, or sickness. Their own or that of someone they love. What do you say upon listening? Thanks for sharing? Good luck with all that? I'm so sorry?

Something has happened, something was shared, that needs to be set apart from every other mundane and silly thing that has happened during the day. The moment needs to be hallowed--set apart, consecrated, made holy.

And so you pray. Prayer is a hallowing. Prayer infuses life with sacred texture. Prayer re-enchants life.

I think about the prayer time before our Sunday School class, a prayer that I often lead. We go around sharing a variety of requests. People are sick. People are traveling. People are struggling. People are broken. People are afraid. And after gathering all these requests, having opened ourselves up to each other, what are we to say in response? "Thanks for sharing everyone," doesn't quite cut it. The moment--where we weep with those who weep and rejoice with those rejoice--needs hallowing. And so we pray. Our sharing wasn't just "catching up" around the water cooler. Something sacred was going on. And so we pray. We hallow.

We are back to existential jujitsu.

True, our doubts and disenchantment cause us to doubt the nature and power of prayer.

But life without prayer? That's hard to imagine. Sometimes prayer is the only appropriate thing to do.

Our disenchantment with a world devoid of prayer edges us back toward enchantment.

Personal Days: Watching a Basketball Game with St. Augustine

Brenden, my oldest son, is in the middle of basketball season. It's been an interesting year in the stands. Our fans have been particularly--Hmmm, how to say this?--vocal and enthusiastic this year. And not in a good way. And the most mortifying thing about this is that we are a Christian school. Christian text and mottoes fill the gym and we start the game with a word of prayer. And still, despite all this, the behavior from our fans is abysmal. Last week our Athletic Director sent an email to the parents of the school reminding them to tone it down. It's sad.

As I still in the stands, as yelling takes place all around me, my mind tends to drift to Augustine.

Our desires are good but disordered. As I watch parents I can't but affirm the goodness of loving your child and wanting the best for him or her. Nor do I fault the love of excellence and effort in the struggle to win in a competition. All these desires are good and loving these things is godly, healthy and appropriate.

But these desires--the love of a child, the desire to win--become disordered when elevated to the highest place. The love of a child becomes disordered when we begin to yell at other children and cheer their failures. The desire to win becomes disordered when we begin to despise the other team and dehumanize the referees.

So, wish us luck this evening. Brenden as a game tonight. That's where I'll be.

Sitting in the stands. Cheering Brenden and the Panthers. Thinking about Augustine.

Fourth Sunday of Advent


The last settlement scraggled out with a barbed wire fence
And fell from sight. They crossed coyote country:
Mesquite, sage, the bunchgrass knotted in patches;
And there the prairie dog yapped in the valley;
And on the high plateau the short-armed badger
Delved his clay. But beyond that the desert,
Raw, unslakable, its perjured dominion wholly contained
In the sun's remorseless mandate, where the dim trail
Died ahead in the watery horizon: God knows where.

And there the failures: skull of the ox,
Where the animal terror trembled on in the hollowed eyes;
The catastrophic wheel, split, sandbedded;
And the sad jawbone of a horse. These the denials
Of the retributive tribes, fiercer than pestilence,
Whose scrupulous realm this was.

Only the burro took no notice: the forefoot
Placed with the nice particularity of one
To who the evil of the day is wholly sufficient.
Even the jocular ears marked time,
But they, the man and the anxious woman,
Who stared pinch-eyed into the settling sun,
They went forward into its denseness
All apprehensive, and would many a time have turned
But for what they carried. That brought them on,
In the gritty blanket they bore the world's great risk,
And knew it; and kept it covered, near to the blind heart,
That hugs in a bad hour its sweetest need,
Possessed against the drawn night
That comes now, over the dead arroyos,
Cold and acrid and black.

This was the first of his goings forth into the wilderness of the world.
There was much to follow: much of portent, much of dread.
But what was so meek then and so mere, so slight and strengthless,
(Too tender, almost, to be touched)--what they nervously guarded
Guarded them. As we, each day, from the lifted chalice,
That strengthless Bread the mildest tongue subsumes,
To be taken out in the blatant kingdom,
Where Herod sweats, and his deft henchmen
Riffle the tabloids--that keeps us.

Over the campfire the desert moon
Slivers the west, too chaste and cleanly
To mean hard luck. The man rattles the skillet
To take the raw edge off the silence;
The woman lifts up her heart; the Infant
Knuckles the generous breast, and feeds.

--"The Flight in the Desert" by Brother Antoninus

The Lost Art of the Church Potluck

My favorite memories of growing up in a small church are of the church potlucks. And that church still puts on awesome potlucks.

I expect that many of you have similar fond memories of church potlucks. Jana does. This last Sunday I was guest speaking at the East Side Church of Christ in Snyder. Jana was weighing if she wanted to go with me. Jana is a high school drama teacher and she was tired because her show just wrapped up and we'd gotten to bed late after striking the set.

I told Jana that after the service there would be a potluck.

"I think I'll come," Jana said, "there might be banana pudding."

And there was!

I don't know if it's a regional thing, but banana pudding is a staple of potlucks in Texas churches. And it's one of the best things you'll ever eat.

And yet, while it breaks my heart to say this, I think the art of the church potluck is on the decline.

We recently had a discussion about this with some friends at church, that potlucks are happening less frequently and, when they do happen, they aren't done very well. A symptom of a potluck gone bad at our church is when the potluck has to be supplemented by Little Caesar's pizza.

So I have to ask, is the Golden Age of the Church Pot Luck over?

It seems so.

With our friends we floated two hypotheses about the decline of the potluck.

The first was church size. It seems that churches are either very big or very small, making it harder to achieve the sweet spot for a congregation-wide potluck.

Our other hypothesis was about a loss of generational skill. The consensus was that our mothers and grandmothers really knew how to do a potluck. And the main thing was that they brought to the potluck a ton of food, enough for their family and many, many more.

And that, we all know, is the secret to having a good potluck. You have to have a critical mass of people bringing more food than they or their families will eat. A lot more food. And our mothers and grandmothers had go-to pot luck dishes to help produce this abundance.

But today the exact opposite happens. When people under forty go to a potluck most everyone brings a small side dish, not even enough for their family. And you don't have to be a resource allocation guru to know that if most people bring less than what they themselves will eat then that potluck is doomed. But more and more often that's what happening with church potlucks, people bring less than what they will consume.

It seems like an entire generation has forgotten the Golden Rule of the church potluck: Bring more that what you will eat. A lot more.

Because it's that excess and abundance that makes the hospitality of a potuck possible, allowing the spontaneous invitation to the visitor who comes empty-handed to be an experience of gift and grace.

Unpublished: Is the Father's Love Stronger Than Death?

A man had two sons. The younger son told his father, "I want my share of your estate now before you die." So his father agreed to divide his wealth between his sons.

A few days later the younger son packed all his belongings and moved to a distant land and there he began to waste all his money in wild living.

Some thieves in the city heard about the money the young man was spending. So one night they attacked the young man when he was alone, killing him and taking all he had. Having told no one where he was from news of the young man's death never reached his hometown.

Years passed.

Each evening the father would scan the horizon, hoping to see his son.

But because he died the son never came home.

--an unpublished parable about salvation and the problem of moral luck, how we need to have an eschatological vision of the Father's love and the prodigal's repentance