In The Book of Love I describe the cross as a “theophany of love.” By this I mean that the cross is the visible manifestation, within history, of the love that God eternally is. In fact, we could describe the whole economy of salvation—creation, covenant, incarnation, cross, resurrection, and the pouring out of the Spirit—as a theophany of love, all the ways in which the love of God is made visible within our world and experience.
While this wasn’t explicitly set out in The Book of Love, I developed this way of thinking about the cross because I wanted an account of the atonement that was consistent with classical theism.
A contrast with penal substitutionary atonement, in regard to classical theism, makes some of my agenda plain. According to classical theism, God is immutable, impassible, simple, and eternal. God is not being among other beings. Nor does God undergo or suffer emotional changes or swings. God does not move from one state to another in a temporal sequence. And God doesn’t suffer under any necessity, compulsion, or demand that constrains his freedom.
All this poses enormous difficulties for penal substitutionary atonement. Specifically, God cannot be conflicted in his posture toward us, undergoing some inner tension between competing impulses like justice and love or holiness and mercy. Nor is it necessary for God to do anything in order to forgive us. There is no sacrificial fix needed. Lastly, there is no change in God’s posture toward us upon the cross: no temporal sequence, no prior posture of wrath that changes toward grace.
All that to say something I’ve said before: classical theism contradicts penal substitutionary atonement. You cannot hold to the orthodox and historical view of God while believing in penal substitutionary atonement.
And yet, this raises a predictable objection. If the cross does not change God, are we left with a merely subjective account of the atonement?
To understand this question, you have to understand how theologians distinguish between subjective and objective theories of atonement.
Subjective theories of atonement focus on what the cross changes in us. The cross reveals God’s love to us, and in response we repent, work to transform our desires, and follow the moral example of love we’ve been provided. All these things are changes inside of us.
By contrast, objective accounts of atonement insist that the cross accomplishes something beyond our subjective responses. Something actually happens, out there in the world so to speak, through Christ that is true whether or not we recognize it.
Given my view that the cross is a theophany of love, I’ve received some pushback since the publication of The Book of Love about whether I am reducing the atonement to the subjective. Many advocates of penal substitutionary atonement defend it because they believe something happened upon the cross, objectively speaking. Their concern, and I recognize this concern as well, is that if there is nothing objective happening upon the cross, then salvation becomes a form of enlightenment, simply having a new subjective experience of God. Proponents of objective theories of atonement insist, however, that something happened in Christ. Something broken was fixed. Some wound was healed.
But you can immediately see my concern here, from a classical theistic perspective: If there was once a wound in our relationship with God and that wound is now healed, well, you’ve just posited a change in the life of God. Which, according to classical theism, is not allowed!
For my part, I recognize the concerns and the challenges here. But as I’ve pondered the objection, I’m having trouble reconciling classical theism with how many “objective” views of the atonement are described. Classical theism raises some questions about what we might mean by “objective.”
Specifically, if objective atonement means that something has to happen in God before God can forgive us, then I don’t see how that can fit with classical theism. The cross cannot be a sacrifice that changes God’s posture toward us, because God does not undergo change. Nor can objective atonement be an event that occurs in time that produces a new reality in the eternal life of God. There can be no “before” and “after” in the life of God.
As I’ve wrestled with these tensions, the best answer I’ve been able to come up with concerns divine condescension.
Here’s the basic idea. God does not change. But we change. And because we change, God’s eternal love is manifested toward us in different ways. That is to say, there is a particularity to the theophany of love depending on how we stand in relation to God.
For example, absent sin, divine love might manifest as participation, blessing, and communion. Absent sin, there wouldn’t be a cross. But once sin enters the picture, that same unchanging and eternal love manifests differently, as judgment, patience, forgiveness, suffering, atonement, and reconciliation.
The change, then, is not in God. The change is in us. Sin changes our relation to God, and therefore changes how God’s unchanging love comes into view within the economy of salvation. This is an objective situation. Sin is not merely a subjective experience or a mistaken perception of reality. Sin is real, and it catastrophically alters our relation to God.
The grief and wrath of God, in this view, come into sight in response to the objective situation caused by sin. Importantly, this display of grief and wrath, as classical theism contends, is synonymous with love. But we’re seeing these particular “colors” of love, to use a metaphor, because of the objective reality of sin. God’s love has not changed. What has changed is the creaturely situation in which God’s love is encountered.
And to repeat, the “colors” of love we see on the cross draw attention to the grievous nature of the objective reality of sin in relation to a just and holy God. The cross makes sin visible. The cross shows us what sin does, not because God needs to be persuaded to forgive us, but because sin is real, as are its consequences.
Stepping back, I don’t know if this approach to the objections concerning objective atonement satisfactorily answers the questions. But, as of today, it’s my best attempt to give an account.
.jpeg)













