Loving as Jesus Loved: C.S. Lewis on Orthopathy

In 2022 I shared some reflections about C.S. Lewis' The Abolition of Man and orthopathy, the Christian call for "right affections." Recently, I was in a conversation about Lewis' argument in The Abolition of Man that sent me back to those reflections. Reading them again, I wanted to pull those reflections into a single piece to make the argument more compact and clear.

C.S. Lewis starts The Abolition of Man by discussing how an English textbook entitled The Green Book makes a comment about the emotion of sublimity when encountering a natural wonder. The textbook authors write:

When the man said 'This is sublime,' he appeared to be making a remark about the waterfall... Actually... he was not making a remark about the waterfall, but a remark about his own feelings.

Lewis cites this remark to illustrate the problem that will sit at the heart of his argument. Specifically, in the modern world, emotion has been disconnected from objective reality. Is the natural wonder, objectively speaking, sublime? If so, emotions of sublimity, wonder, and awe are appropriate to the encounter. And other emotions, such as indifference or boredom, are less appropriate.

As Lewis says later in his lecture, until quite recently people believed that "objects did not merely receive, but could merit, our approval or disapproval, our reverence or our contempt." A person who called the cataract sublime wasn't simply describing their own feelings. They were claiming that the object was one which merited those feelings.

This is what Lewis means by right affections. Our emotions can be right or wrong because they can be appropriate or inappropriate to reality. As Lewis describes it, "St Augustine defines virtue as ordo amoris, the ordinate condition of the affections in which every object is accorded that kind of degree of love which is appropriate to it." Lewis also cites Aristotle, who stated that the aim of education is to make the pupil like and dislike what he ought.

And it is here where Lewis' famous "men without chests" passage comes in.

You might have heard that line before and mistakenly assumed it to mean that the modern world is making men timid, cowardly, and "unmanly." But that's not really Lewis' point. Although Lewis uses martial courage as his illustration, his argument isn't primarily about masculinity and bravery. His point is about emotion and value. Specifically, Lewis' audience had lived through two world wars, so the example of loyalty and bravery on the battlefield was poignant and powerful. But it's important to notice what Lewis was arguing for with the example of courage. Loyalty and bravery are virtues because they converge upon a good. They are emotions responding appropriately to a value.

As Lewis puts it:

Without the aid of trained emotions the intellect is powerless against the animal organism. I had sooner play cards against a man who was quite sceptical about ethics, but bred to believe that ‘a gentleman does not cheat’, than against an irreproachable moral philosopher who had been brought up among sharpers. In battle it is not syllogisms that will keep the reluctant nerves and muscles to their post in the third hour of the bombardment.

In battle, syllogisms do not keep the reluctant nerves and muscles at their post during the third hour of the bombardment. Something more than reason is required. We don't die for logic. We die for love.

But that raises a deeper question. Is loving your country a value, a good? If so, courage in battle is virtuous and praiseworthy. And cowardice is lamentable. But if feelings are mere feelings and tell us nothing about value, then how can we pass any moral judgment upon heroes and cowards?

That question brings us to the crux of Lewis' argument about right affections. Virtue requires the existence of objective value. Without objective value, our emotions become privatized and subjective. Courage and cowardice are simply feelings. Compassion and indifference are simply feelings. Anger and tranquility are simply feelings. There is no way to say that one affection is appropriate and another inappropriate because there is no objective reality to which those affections can be properly ordered.

The point for Lewis isn't that the modern world is vanishing men. The modern world is, rather, vanishing value. And when value goes, so does courage, along with all the other virtues we aspire to.

In his second lecture, Lewis goes on to make an argument for objective value. Interestingly, for the Anglican Christian, Lewis calls the source of objective value the Tao.

The Tao is "the Way" or "the Path." The Tao traces the moral grain of the universe, and wisdom is coming to live with that grain. Right living is living in harmony and attunement with the Tao, the ordering principle and flow of the cosmos. The Tao provides an immanent ground of value.

Christianity is no stranger to this idea. In both the Old and New Testaments, creation is imbued with a moral grain. Creation isn't inert matter. Creation crackles with value.

In the Old Testament, the Tao is called Wisdom. Proverbs presents Wisdom as present from the beginning, participating in the ordering of creation and calling us into a way of life:

The Lord brought me forth as the first of his works,
before his deeds of old;
I was formed long ages ago,
at the very beginning, when the world came to be. (Proverbs 8:22-23)

And in the New Testament, Wisdom becomes associated with the Logos, the Word:

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was with God in the beginning. Through him all things were made. (John 1:1-3)

As Paul says of Christ:

All things have been created through him and for him. He is before all things, and in him all things hold together. (Colossians 1:16-17)

The point is that reality has a grain. Things have a proper order. Some things are worthy of love, some of contempt, some of compassion, some of courage. And Christian virtue involves learning to respond to reality accordingly.

Which brings me back to my interest in The Abolition of Man.

Christianity has tended to privilege orthodoxy—right belief—over things like orthopraxy, right practice, and orthopathy, right affection. We spend a great deal of time discussing what Christians should believe and what Christians should do. We talk about prayer, Sabbath, Bible study, and fasting. And while these things certainly involve our affections, we rarely place emotions at the center of spiritual formation. We rarely describe these practices as habits of orthopathy.

The goal of spiritual formation isn't simply to think like Jesus or act like Jesus. The goal of spiritual formation is also to love what Jesus loves. The right ordering of our affections. Our emotional attunement with the Tao.

A series of questions then presents itself. What did Jesus love? What made Jesus rejoice? What made him weep? What moved him with compassion? What made him angry? What did he find beautiful? What did he find intolerable? Whom did he welcome? Whom did he admire? Whom did he pity?

Such questions move us beyond the idea that emotions are simply private psychological states. The questions ask us to consider whether our affections are becoming congruent with reality as revealed in Christ. The purpose of spiritual disciplines is to make us people who love rightly.

Perhaps Christian spiritual formation can be described this way: the formation of our affections into the affections of Christ. Christian maturity is learning to love what is lovable, hate what is hateful, grieve what is grievous, rejoice in what is good, and desire what is beautiful. All in the way Jesus does.

So ask yourself: What is your heart up to? Moment by moment, and day by day?

Are you displaying the emotions and affections of Jesus?

This entry was posted by Richard Beck. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply